Challenging current techniques

By Frank Massey | Published:  18 July, 2017

Frank Massey looks at how you need to always keep an open mind on diagnostic methods

Accepting my reservations, I always believe in challenging any current techniques with an open mind with the possibility that a better method may exist. My reservations are based on the following reasons.

Reservations

Electronic measurements are based on sensor signatures compared with known confirmed values. Many engines now employ variable valve lift and timing. Added to this complexity, often there is no mechanical locking of sprockets to shafts. Confirming actual mechanical camshaft position regarding the crankshaft would require sensors monitoring all camshafts and all sprockets.

With exception of highly advanced engines this is not the case. So how can we predict actual valve functionality before opening the spanner drawer?

Functionality

Recently we filmed a detailed diagnostic process with Pico exploring a reliable method. Determining electronic plausibility is relativity easy. The answer to actual valve operation is reliant on accurate pressure evaluation in the cylinder. This must be overlaid in real time with the timing sensor signatures. There is still an element of error as you will need to calculate camshaft rotational angle against the crankshaft profile. The Pico software helps by converting the oscilloscope base line into the 4-stroke rotational position. So far so good, but can poor mechanical condition be predicted more easily? Well yes it can, remember the vacuum gauge. Volumetric efficiency is directly proportional to correct valve position.

Hang on a moment; Where should the valve position be? It’s not simply a function of a chain or timing belt. The computer now has an opinion on optimum timing angle. It’s not that easy anymore. However, I do support the premise of predictive evidence.

Boxter

Let’s visit an actual event in our workshop from very recently; a Porsche Boxter 3.4 supported with Bosch Motronic med control. With no obvious cause or warning it developed a drop in power and throttle response. No definitive DTC. You didn’t think I was going to make it that easy for did you?

Serial data confirmed two key symptoms. Misfire count and rich fuel trim more than 20% on one bank only. It is a low mileage car with no obvious signs of poor care. Removing the spark plugs confirmed excessive soot as the symptoms of incomplete combustion. Note my words carefully. Further examination excluded the unlikely cause as poor ignition energy. Back to basics, the vacuum gauge confirmed too high pressure in the intake system specific to the offending bank. The next action was to attach the pressure transducer to each bank in turn comparing the pressure profiles.

Direct measurement

To achieve this, direct measurement from each bank is required. Running the engine with the pressure sensor directly in one cylinder from each bank confirmed a differential in pressure between banks. It must be a mechanical problem then. The next decision is more intuitive than evidence driven as this engine has variable valve timing adjustment via electro-hydraulic control.

Serial data could not provide actual camshaft position data though, as the sensor is only motoring the sprocket position. This is the very point I made earlier. We could get clever and monitor control duty cycle and current through each actuator. Unfortunately, the computer does not monitor a problem, so there will not be any correction made.

Complete restoration

Examination of the service history confirmed long life servicing. This prompted us to flush the engine and replace both hydraulic camshaft control actuators. This resulted in a complete restoration of performance; obviously, we reset the adaption values to fuel trim, throttle angle and misfire count.

As is often the case, a combination of hard evidence and common sense prevailed. I often say to entry level diagnostic students, the most complex problem in diagnostics is you.

Further information
Please contact Annette on:
01772 201 597 or email enquiries@ads-global.co.uk for further information on upcoming training courses and events.

Related Articles

  • UFI Filters enhances UK offering 

  • Under pressure 

    Even apparently simple problems require thorough investigation if you want to diagnose faults right the first time

  • The future of DPF servicing 

    Two months from now will bring my tenure in the motor industry to 49 years. I would like to think I have evolved, kept up with technology, enabling me to provide a professional service, enjoying customer respect and integrity. My focus has been the technical challenges, while my son David manages the commercial responsibilities.

  • Let go of my Lego 

    "Electronic Lego" is a phrase that was introduced to me by an engineering manager when I worked for the diagnostic company Crypton around 25 years ago. In the late 1980s the Company had developed engine tuning machines which moved away from bespoke central processing units (the so called Big Box tuners) to a PC based system. The elements of the PC based system could not just be bought and fitted together (like lego) and be expected to work. The PC components and peripherals had to be carefully selected, including the compatibility of their drivers and software to ensure a robust PC based diagnostic machine could be created. Over the past 10 years or so motor vehicles have moved away from their previous Lego like construction, where replacement parts were free to be plugged in and replaced at will. The change was due partly to the modern vehicle being constructed as a rolling network of computers and partly to the advent of the factory fitted immobiliser, where transponder keys and the relationship between vehicle computers became prevalent.

  • The Tools for the job  

    I gave this topic some considerable thought before choosing to discuss not just a selection of tools we use, but also some tools we have designed and modified.


Search

Sign Up

For the latest news and updates from Aftermarket Magazine.


Poll

Where should the next Automechanika show be held?



Calendar

Click here to submit an event

Facebook


©DFA Media 1999-2016

Mentés