Perfect Timing

Using fault codes as vital clues leads Andy Crook to the root cause

Published:  19 November, 2014

A customer presented us with a VW T4 van demonstrating a lack of power and difficulty starting hot or cold - in fact, it wouldn't start at all once it was turned off. A visual check revealed little evidence, due to the number of covers and shields in place. A quick code read was taken and the following diagnostic trouble code (DTC) was logged in the ECU memory - P1248 Start of injection timing regulation: Control deviation.

Codes are often helpful, in fact, they are often very accurate. This often results in technicians taking the code at face value and ordering whatever component is being flagged by the DTC. In this situation, it would be easy to simply blame the timing solenoid, as this is the component that controls the injection advance. However, you need to make sure you are getting to the real problem and not just treating a symptom. You should be thinking:

Then an appropriate test routine can be devised and logical tests carried out to confirm or deny the presence of faults.

Delve deeper

So, let's take a look at each of these questions...

Does the code match the symptoms?

What else could cause this code to be logged by the ECU?

What sensor(s) are responsible for monitoring this code?

What actuator is responsible for this output?

What mechanical functions are influenced, or influence, the operation of this sub system?

What tests should be carried out to determine the root cause and in what order? Well, in my experience, whatever you choose to test last is bound to be the cause, so I tend to perform the tests in the order of accessibility. The first on the list is questioning the customer i.e. 'Have you run out of fuel recently?' In this case, with the symptoms being present at the time of testing it is unlikely to be the cause of the DTC but it is worth looking through the service history and checking if the symptoms coincide with any previous work.

The timing solenoid itself is easily accessible and is fed with a live and a switched ground, it is best checked with an oscilloscope when the engine is running. This tested OK, as did the crankshaft sensor and needle lift sensor.

The root cause

The cam timing and pump belts were next on the checklist and the pump belt was found to be saturated in oil. This had resulted in stripped teeth. After removing the pump belt it seemed logical to send the pump away to be checked and calibrated.

With the oil leak and two separate water leaks repaired with new seals, hoses and clips, the belt was replaced. The timing was checked using the VCDS (VAG-COM Diagnostic System) timing checker and then adjusted. You can see the injection timing on the vertical axis versus fuel temperature on the horizontal axis in Figure 2.

The Van was taken on a test drive and checked for correct performance, DTC's and leaks. The root cause was the oil leak, which resulted in the damaged drive belt. I have checked the DTC list and I can't find a single code that replaces the technician's ability to analyse, test and diagnose based on the evidence gathered. The DTC is just one piece of evidence, it should not be the only piece you rely on if you want to find the root cause.

Related Articles

  • A slippery situation 

    There is more to oil than simply putting it in the filler cap and making sure the levels are correct. It lubricates, reduces friction and helps an engine to perform at the peak of its power.

  • It's all in the timing 

    A job I was recently asked to look at had a bit of an odd symptom; it would run (apparently quite well), as long as the camshaft position sensor was unplugged. The previous history on the vehicle, a 2009 2.5 TDI VW Transporter, was very limited. During my initial inspection, I noticed that the vehicle was suffering from a slightly extended cranking time, which is quite normal for a cam sensor related issue, as the engine ECU cannot easily calculate which TDC is which.

  • Bearing in mind 

    Wheel bearings are a component of the vehicle where friction is detrimental to their activity. The bearing must remain free and smooth in its workings in order to ensure the wheel can rotate without impediment.

  • Staying in control

  • Tools that build trust 

    Matt Lamming, Diagnostic Product Specialist at Snap-on, explains how storing and sharing vehicle fault code data can ensure repeat business

Most read content


Sign Up

For the latest news and updates from Aftermarket Magazine.


Where should the next Automechanika show be held?


©DFA Media 1999-2018