Let’s get it started...

Frank Massey looks at how to get to grips with ignition combustion diagnostics which is an increasingly complex subject

Ignition primary good earth path

Published:  22 October, 2018

Let me begin with the simplest of all overviews: There are four possible causes of combustion failure or malfunction; and please note my refusal to use the word misfire. The word is meaningless without a definitive confirmed diagnosis. The four possible causes are:

  •  Insufficient delivery of ignition energy
  •  Incorrect fuel air composition
  •  A mechanical defect
  •  A control error

I also have a very firm opinion as to the selection and reliability of diagnostic tools when looking at ignition. Serial diagnostics has improved so much that I am prepared to use it, with the qualification that it is for guidance only. For example, identifying a cylinder, the number of misfire events, ignition timing angle, coil saturation time, and in some cases, spark burn duration, ignition set back etc.

I am excluding for the moment other vital supporting data such as exhaust oxygen sensors feedback, exit temperatures, load request data, etc. what I am focusing on is it possible to accurately assess the spark energy delivery characteristics other than with an oscilloscope? The answer is no.

Critical characteristics
The reality is that given the complexity and integrated reliance on other system components and function, it is often a mandatory requirement to apply several tests to accurately confirm not just failure symptoms , but cause too. The four  critical characteristics of good ignition energy delivery are:
Burn time. Critical observations; Exposure time, slope, and spark turbulence are all vital in understanding the transition of energy across the spark delivery path. Expect smooth transition at idle, turbulence on load.

 Ignition primary current profile. Critical observations; Peak value fall time of inductance, vital when confirming if the problem of poor energy delivery is a primary or secondary issue. Expect near vertical transition with undershoot.

Coil ringing. Critical observations;  This is the electrical resonance that is characteristic when switching current within an inductor. It determines the winding insulation integrity, and predicts a breach or shunt that will reduce the spark burn time and lead to eventual ignition failure. Expect three events.

 Firing line voltage. Critical observations;  Strictly speaking this is normally viewed in primary, however can be assessed in secondary where access is not available to pin 1. The shape or ignition profile would more normally resemble a wardrobe on it side rather than stood up! It represents the circuit load from the coil tower and includes the spark plug. Expect direct ignition 30v, waisted spark 40v, rotating ignition 50v.

I am not aware of any actual measurement data existence within manufacturers TBs, or be available serially. This is something I looked at over 30 years ago and was ridiculed by many.

Incorrect air fuel composition is an equally complex subject,  however  this can be in part successfully complemented with the use of serial data. Monitoring live data during a dynamic drive cycle can reveal possible symptoms, but not the cause of a problem.  Air fuel ratio, load request, fuel trim, fuel delivery status, ie homogenous or stratified, all of which should be evaluated against request, actual, and corrected data.

It doesn’t end there though. The hydraulic and mechanical dynamics of fuel delivery through the injector must be fully understood and tested. Intake air turbulence, swirl flaps, tumble and drumble characteristics, are all dramatically affected by valve and intake carbon deposits,  especially on direct injection systems that do not have the advantages of dual port injection. Mechanical defects are probably as complex to confirm as disassembly or removal is often needed to fully examine the serial or oscilloscope evidence. Many engines now require spark plugs to be precisely torqued to ensure the ignition energy is delivered to an exact position within the cylinder. How would you diagnose that?  Ignition energy across the plug would be normal, load request data would match, air fuel ratios normal.

Incomplete combustion or an anomaly as I call them could be the result of mechanical or cooling defects. These can  include piston crown mapped oil cooling jets, cylinder cooling, valve seat irregularities, valve to piston timing, injector flow and atomisation issues, or ignition energy incompatibility with the internal cylinder condition.

The only useful evidence may include, cylinder misfire count, oxygen sensor irregularities, excess oxygen and increased HCs in the exhaust stream. Any of you guys out there remember the good old days when 4-gas exhaust analysis was the craft of every professional engine tuner?

So here we are around 800 words to just touch on an incredibly complex subject. In the past the cure would have been relatively straightforward. Today it will destroy the engine, with prestige manufacturers like Porsche currently suffering multiple major engine failures. Techs need to think smarter.

Ignition primary poor earth path

Related Articles

  • Attitudes to training: Autoinform-ed  

    I have had a few weeks to reflect on an incredible Autoinform Live technical weekend in Cork Ireland. This took place at the premises of J&S Automotive on Saturday 27 and Sunday 28 April. My first thoughts, thanks, and appreciation must go to our hosts, the guest presenters, delegates, and contributing organisations which made this event possible.
    Specifically focusing on our hosts, J&S Automotive were so accommodating, words alone would not do their contribution justice. To dismantle their warehouse, provide catering and the most impressive quality support and welcome was really going above and beyond.

    Sharing knowledge
    Following the two days, I have become reflective about the way technicians approach training worldwide. I have been involved in the motor I industry for well over 50 years, with around 35 years providing training. I have and still travel the globe meeting and sharing knowledge. Please note the sharing expression, as I feel privileged to have met so many dedicated technicians from a variety of backgrounds. I have witnessed over the years great change in attitude and commitment from independent technicians and garage owners.

    I also have noted a big discrepancy in commitment from some UK I dependants which contrast with overseas counterparts.
    There is I believe a complacency in attitude to the future challenges. One recent illustration comes to mind. While in Australia last October, an individual from Perth heard on the kangaroo vine that a series of seminars was taking place in Sydney. So he could attend, he closed his business on Wednesday night with 24 hours notice, booked a eight hour flight and joined the event for the Saturday and Sunday.

    Meanwhile, a little near home, I have had cancellations from delegates unwilling to travel 10-15 miles due to unforeseen last-minute changes. I hope they are reading this!

    Threats and challenges
    So where does this leave our industry and what are the immediate threats and challenges? In my view, these can be summed up as ignorance, arrogance, complacency, and the biggest of all; technical and political evolution.

    I don’t share the euphoria of hybrid, battery, or autonomous vehicles, however I do accept the impact these will have in the short-lived near-future. In my opinion two evolutionary changes will have a long lasting influence. These are hydrogen cell technology, and cradle-to-grave vehicle utilisation. Why own a vehicle when for a relatively small affordable rental you could use and return the vehicle in exchange for a new model after two years. No depreciation, no maintenance, no trade in. As for the other aforementioned technologies, less wear, less maintenance, less reliance on the independent garage sector.

    Back to boots on the ground: The technical evolution has quite literally been breath-taking. This has in the short term presented incredible opportunities for aggressive technical minded business owners and technicians. With opportunity comes challenge, investment and training. Complex vehicle systems require a comprehensive sound knowledge and infrastructure to provide a competitive service against the dealership network. Many garages out there are currently servicing and repairing systems without adequate knowledge or technical hardware to comply with original build spec requirements. Please do not take that comment as a cheap swipe without redress but a genuine helpful comment in realisation by how much this industry has changed. In comparison with other less technical trades, controlled by rigorous legislation we have been left to our own devices so far.

    Confident system diagnosis
    I was among the presenters at Autoinform Live. Obviously what I have just gone through is a very broad analysis, so for my segment I concentrated on more specific area. With this in mind, my presentation at the event focused on using available technology to combat the ever increasing difficulties in confident systems diagnosis. In particular, I focused on engine efficiency, pumping losses, and very accurate assent of valve piston relationship using a pressure transducer while the engine is running. I then expanded on cylinder balance using g vibration analysis.

    If you are running a business, you will doubtlessly be interested in getting into the next era, but this may require some adaptation on your part. You also need to put yourself in the correct area. Like the dinosaurs before us, there is an extinction zone out there and the asteroid will hit our I industry sooner than you might like or think. If you are in the 10 mile radius training mindset then you really do need to lift you focus on the horizon or possibly to those businesses you resent or admire who are succeeding in your area. If you are one of those success stories then you already know me and are attending Autoinform events or something similar.

  • Get fresh with Spring Garage Essentials 

    The Parts Alliance’s Spring Garage Essentials catalogue has been released, and features a huge number of new suppliers and exclusive products.

  • New Sun One-Person Testing Car Scissor Lift 

    The new Sun SSL 6350 scissor lift can be installed into current MOT bay recesses to replace older four-post lifts – and requires no additional groundworks.  The inclusion of shaker plates gives the SSL 6350 the functionality to be operated by just one person during a test, freeing up another technician to take on more jobs and be more productive. Ideal also for new MOT sites with limited space, the SSL 6350 has a lifting capacity of 3500kg and meets the DVSA requirements for testing of Class IV vehicles. The SSL 6350 is also a solution for current MOT stations wanting to bring their equipment up to date while minimising disruption to their businesses.

  • Hunter Revolution WalkAway  

    Hunter’s fully-automatic Revolution WalkAway tyre changer offers 80 seconds of unattended bead breaking and demounting, meaning that technicians can perform other tasks such as wheel balancing while other tyres within a set are being demounted. Indeed, with the new WalkAway tyre changer, Hunter estimates that the process of changing and balancing a complete set of four identical wheels and tyres is 25% faster than traditional methods.The new Revolution WalkAway is ideal for workshops who are changing a large number of end-of-life tyres in sets of four or two of same size tyre and wheel assemblies.

  • Four wheel aligner compatibility  

    The Bluetooth Pro Wheel Aligner from Absolute Alignment is fully wireless to ensure fast and easy use, and can be used with four and two-post lifts and in-ground wheel-free scissor lifts. The direct contact charging and calibration system means the whole wheel alignment package is 100% cable free for a safe workshop.  Absolute Alignment supplies an array of wheel alignment equipment to suit workshops of all sizes, and is the only UK provider with a full range of Bluetooth wheel aligners suitable for cars and commercial vehicles – including those equipped with the latest generation of ADAS.

Most read content


Sign Up

For the latest news and updates from Aftermarket Magazine.


Where should the next Automechanika show be held?


Click here to submit an event


©DFA Media 1999-2019